The Parts Analysis and
Assurance (PA&A) group at the Johnson Space Center (JSC) evaluated
the PowerCache Ultracapacitor, part number PC5, from Maxwell Technology.
These capacitors are used in the ISS PEEK (Portable Electrical Equipment
Kit). The PEEK hardware provides electrical power extension cables
and outlets as well as 120 to 28Vdc converter units to power portable
electrical hardware on the ISS.
Ultracapacitors, also
known as double-layer capacitors, incorporate new technology and
material not used in other capacitors. The ultracapacitor stores
electrostatic energy by polarizing the electrolytic solution and
can be charged and discharged hundreds of thousands of times. An
electrode-electrolyte interface with activated carbon fibers allows
obtaining extremely high capacitance per unit area. There are several
methods of construction, but JSC tested one where an insulator separates
two activated carbon electrodes. These electrodes consist of an
aluminum foil with a carbon binder mixture deposited in it. The
set is tightly rolled with leads attached to the aluminum foils.
An electrolyte is added and the component is sealed.
This technology is suited
for applications where there is a need of providing large bursts
of power, for fractions of seconds up to several minutes, with the
ability of rapid recharge. During a power outage, power levels from
the ultracapacitor can be held until power returns. Due to their
large energy storage capability, ultracapacitors have found applications
in the electric vehicle industry, memory back-up devices in appliances
such as videocassette recorders, typewriters, wristwatches, and
measuring devices. The advantage of ultracapacitors is that they
are smaller in size than other capacitors of the same value. This
allows for greater packaging efficiency. The typical voltage rating
for a single ultracapacitor is 2.3Vdc. The components can be stacked
in series to achieve the proper operating voltage for any specific
application.
Space Application
The PEEK project had
the JSC RITF (Receiving and Inspection Test Facility) evaluate these
commercial capacitors to determine their suitability in space flight
hardware. The evaluation consisted of a series of tests to determine
their performance across a range of environmental stress conditions.
The following tests were conducted:
- Visual Inspection
- Fine Leak Test
- Accelerated Life (Six
tests)
- Static Burn-in (five
tests)
- Reverse Bias
- Self-Heat via Rapid
Charge-Discharge (three tests)
- Over Voltage Pulse
(eleven tests)
- Thermal Shock (one
test)
- Destructive Physical
Analysis
- Electrical Parameter
testing at periodic intervals
The RITF test results
demonstrate that the ultracapacitor is suitable for use in the ISS
PEEK hardware, as well as in other equipment that is used in ISS
manned pressurized modules. Ultracapacitor pedigree in military
or aerospace applications is presently not available and no specific
standard has been developed for screening and testing purposes.
However, the PowerCache ultracapacitor survived the environmental
tests in MIL-STD-810 "Environmental Engineering Considerations and
Laboratory Tests". A series of tests were performed at JSC Receiving
Inspection and Test Facility (RITF) to determine the reliability
of the ultracapacitor under different conditions. The PC5 ultracapacitor
is rated at 4 Farads at 2.7Vdc maximum and the operating temperature
is between -20ºC to +70ºC.
Investigation
Fifteen ultracapacitors
were tested, all receiving the fine leak test and visual inspection.
The ultracapacitors are hermetically sealed; therefore, the fine
leak test was performed in accordance with MIL-STD-883 test method
1014 during initial inspection and at the completion of all tests.
The ultracapacitors did not exceed the leakage limit imposed by
the test method.
The ultracapacitors were
divided into groups of five and ten. Ten ultracapacitors received
accelerated life tests, which consisted of six dynamic tests. The
ultracapacitors were charged-discharged cycled 6000 times, at three
different temperatures (-20ºC, +25ºC and 65ºC). They were first
cycled 1000 times and then 5000 times. The charge voltage was 2.3V
and each cycle was approximately 1.5 minutes in duration. They were
subjected to a total of 18000 cycles. The monitored parameters (C,
ESR, and LC) did not change significantly as a result of these tests.
A total of 480 hours
of static burn-in while charged at 2.5V was performed on the ten
ultracapacitors. The burn-in consisted of 96 hours at +60ºC, 48
hours at 20ºC, 48 hours at 5ºC, 48 hours at 0ºC and
240 hours at +85ºC. The 240 hours of burn-in resulted in a change
in capacitance, ESR and LC. However, the parameters remained within
the manufacturers specification.
For the reverse bias
test 5 ultracapacitors were connected in reverse polarity. They
operated this way for 5000 charge-discharge cycles at 65ºC. The
duration of the cycles was approximately 1.5 minutes in duration.
After 5000 cycles, the capacitance of the 5 ultracapacitors was
reduced to almost half and the ESR almost tripled.
Ten ultracapacitors were
subjected to 100 cycles of thermal shock between 55ºC to 85ºC.
The ultracapacitors were not connected to any circuit or power for
this test. No significant change in the parameters resulted at the
completion of the test.
Two ultracapacitors were
tested for self-heat via rapid charge-discharge. The test consisted
of charge-discharge at a rate fast enough to cause internal heating.
When the desired temperature was reached, the ultracapacitors continued
to be cycled for five minutes at that temperature. No significant
change in the parameters resulted from the test.
Two ultracapacitors were
subjected to over voltage pulse test. The test consisted of voltage
pulses of varying amplitude and of varying duration. The test did
not result in significant change in the parameters.
Destructive Physical
Analysis (DPA) was performed in accordance to MIL-STD-1580 on a
sample. The sample was a representation of the 15 ultracapacitors.
The sample was examined externally and internally. No anomalies
were found.
Conclusion
One test, the reverse
bias test, caused damage to the ultracapacitor as expected. These
are polarized devices and are not to be used in reverse polarity.
In all the other tests, the ultracapacitors continue to work as
advertised within the specification. The 240 hours of burn-in at
85ºC, resulted in drift of capacitance, ESR and LC. However, this
change was never beyond the specification and the capacitor continued
to work properly. Two of the tests designed to overstress the part,
self-heat via rapid charge-discharge and the over voltage pulse,
did not cause any damage.
The results of these
tests show that the PowerCache ultracapacitor from Maxwell is highly
reliable when used within the manufacturers specification.
The series of tests performed on the ultracapacitor showed the suitability
of the device in the space flight crew compartment. The ultracapacitor
demonstrated that it could operate beyond the manufacturers
operating parameters. However, care must be taken in the operating
temperature. The ultracapacitor operating temperature is 20ºC
to +70ºC but the space and military operating temperatures exceed
this range.